Docker, LiteSpeed, and Lucee/Tomcat (ColdFusion) - Creating an image to share with all

Discussion in 'Install/Configuration' started by oranuf, Mar 23, 2018.

  1. oranuf

    oranuf Member

    I am in the process of creating a Docker image with a very specific configuration:
    • Debian 9.3
    • Latest version of LiteSpeed
    • Lucee
    Upon which I may base additional ColdFusion apps (CFWheels, Mura). I am working to make it as "generic" as possible, so that others may pull the docker image and be up and running with LS and CF in a matter of minutes. It is my way to give back to both the LS and CF/Lucee communities, and gain further exposure for the LiteSpeed server, which through WordPress installs I have grown to really enjoy and see great beneft.

    I am seeking assistance as I work through the process, as I know I am missing some basic information.

    So far, i have heavily tweaked the one-click install script for LiteSpeed, such that it is nearly bare-bones, specifically for Debian 9, and serves only one purpose - to download and install LiteSpeed. I am using this stripped down one-click script as part of my Dockerfile that builds the image, but for the purposes of this discussion, I feel pretty confident that we can ignore that Docker is even in the mix - for now, I am working within a container already, to try and configure LiteSpeed and Lucee/Tomcat to play well together, and try to figure out how the caching would work, based on my existing experience with the WordPress plugin. If I am successful, I may even be able to develop a similar plugin for Mura.

    I am working off of the premise that almost everything configuration-wise will be done in the *virtual host* configuration file. This is to keep things as simple as possible, since the whole point of this being a Docker image is that it will provide only one service - HTML/ColdFusion page generation and serving, for one single app. If I can distribute the Docker image with the server configuration as solid as possible and making it easy for the user of the Docker image to customize the install by editing a single vhost file and .htaccess, this seems like an ideal distribution.

    So far, I have installed both LS and Lucee, and by adding a virtual host in Lucee's server.xml file, combined with the LS vhost, I am able to serve .cfm pages without issue from a virtual host well beyond the LS Example host. This seems like a pretty good milestone already, though I don't know if I've made the connection in the most efficient manner. Here's what I have so far, within the docker container:
    • Created the following directories:
      • /srv/APP/httpd - this becomes the vhost root. Permissions for this directory and all subdirectories are set to nobody:nogroup, except for the conf directory mentioned below;

      • /srv/APP/httpd/www - this becomes the vhost DOCUMENT root;

      • /srv/APP/httpd/conf - this is where the vhost config file resides (the LS admin will NOT let one put a vhost config file outside $SERVER_ROOT, so I'm apparently breaking a rule here... i programmed this location into the Litespeed httpd_config.conf file, and set permissions on this directory to lsadm:lsadm to get this to work;

      • /srv/APP/httpd/logs - this is where the vhost LOGS will be written.
    • Created listeners for my APP, both standard ( : 80) and SSL ( : 443) in the httpd_config.conf file. For now, the SSL listener uses the same LiteSpeed certificates in use by the LiteSpeed admin;

    • Set up my vhost file (again, /srv/APP/httpd/conf/vhconf.conf) as follows:
      docRoot                   $VH_ROOT/www
      errorlog $VH_ROOT/logs/error.log {
        useServer               0
        logLevel                NOTICE
        rollingSize             64M
      accesslog $VH_ROOT/logs/access.log {
        useServer               0
        logFormat               <<<END_logFormat
      %h %l %u %t \"%r\" %>s %b \"%{Referer}i\" \"%{User-agent}i\
        logHeaders              7
        rollingSize             64M
        keepDays                60
        bytesLog                $VH_ROOT/logs/bytes.log
        compressArchive         1
      index  {
        useServer               0
        indexFiles              index.cfm
      scripthandler  {
        add                     servlet:Lucee cfm
      extprocessor Lucee {
        type                    servlet
        address                 localhost:8009
        maxConns                1000
        pcKeepAliveTimeout      -1
        initTimeout             15
        retryTimeout            15
        respBuffer              0
      context / {
        type                    null
        location                $DOC_ROOT
        allowBrowse             1
        enableExpires           1
        indexFiles              index.cfm
        rewrite  {
          enable                1
          inherit               0
      rewriteFile           $DOC_ROOT/.htaccess
        addDefaultCharset       off
       enableIpGeo             1
    ...and this file has enabled .cfm files to be passed from LiteSpeed to Lucee for processing - i can call https://localhost/index.cfm, and get an updated date/time output with each page refresh.​
    • attempted to set up the .htaccess file in the $DOC_ROOT, so that caching could be enabled. Initially I had a cache module configured at the server level, but again, I'd rather have the configuration stick as closely as possible to the vhost or .htaccess file as possible.

      When I had the cache module configured in LSAdmin at the server level, I turned on public and private (set =1) and EVERYTHING was cached, including my dynamic ColdFusion page... so I know the configuration between CF and LS *does* work and is capable of caching. It's just that I cannot remove the cache module from the server level and enable it in .htaccess, and have it work.
    1. How do I enable caching at the vhost level for my Lucee/ColdFusion site, using .htaccess? The instructions in the Wiki all appear to be for an older version of LSWS, and I'm not sure which ones apply in this situation anyway.

    2. How do I configure the cache to work similar to the base WordPress/LSCache install, but for a custom app or a CMS like Mura? It is a given that static resources should be cached, but the dynamic pages are the fly in the ointment of course. Once I get caching working, I obviously have to make sure I balance out the caching with the nature of dynamic pages - I can't have a page that should show the current date/time on each request simply kick out the date/time of the page as it exists in the cache =D ... so I need to have a basis for caching that not only *I* can live with, but a "safe" configuraiton with some options, hopefully configured via .htaccess, for any other person wishing to jump start their project using my Docker image of this configuration.

    My (awesome) experience with LSWS/LSCache so far has really been in the context of the WordPress plugin, which works absolutely great... LS seems to know when these dynamic PHP pages have actually changed, and serves them up fresh, but then serves them from the cache for a set period of time, optimizing the entire WordPress install. It's been excellent for all my WordPress clients, but to be honest, I don't quite know how it does it. The WP plugin seems to modify .htaccess, but I'm not sure if that's all it's doing. I tried using the .htaccess rules from a WordPress site, but they didn't work, and I was (and *AM*) getting errors in the server-level error log regarding invalid htaccess directives, even though they seem to work for WordPress sites without issue.

    So I'd like to have some idea of how the WordPress-based install of LSWS/LSCache "does its thing" so well, so I can attempt to do the same with a CF site, or a CF-based CMS like Mura. This is more along the lines of the philosophical approach to caching in LSWS in addition to the more straightforward "do this in your config" suggestions I may need.

    I am happy to provide whatever additional info is required of course, and also include credit to anyone when it comes time to distribute the Docker image, for any assistance provided. My preference would be to work closely with LiteSpeed folks to deliver this very specialized Docker image first, and then genericize it to more OS's beyond Debian 9.3, as the one-click install script provides. I wanted to eliminate as many variables as possible first, but hope to expand the configuration over time.

    So there it is... sorry for the length just to ask what are probably very simple questions... but if you have recommendations on how to get these two technologies working as efficient and powerfully as possible together, I'm ready to dig in.

    ~ oranuf
    Last edited by a moderator: Mar 26, 2018
  2. Pong

    Pong Well-Known Member Staff Member

  3. oranuf

    oranuf Member

    I hit a complete brick wall with this. Ignoring the caching questions for the moment, the showstopper has been, of all things, FORM SUBMITS. I can configure an External App and Script Handler and Context to work with Tomcat/Lucee, and I thought all was well, until I went to try and log in to the Lucee administrator. The login page loads, but when I submit the form, the server just spins until a 503 appears. So then i tried with my own simple test.cfm file, with a form POST that submits to itself. Again, the test.cfm file loads fine, but when i submit the form, nothing but a stall and then a 503.

    I have looked at EVERYTHING, at least five times. No clues in any log files, no reason why GETs should work but POSTs do not. Never seen anything like it. Has caused me to consider building out an nginx image instead, because I simply have no clue why what shoudl be a simple AJP configuration would fail like this. I've wasted over two days on it and of course being this community support, answers are slow to come by and probably not as qualified as a paid support channel would be.

    Pretty disappointed, not just for the time I've burned, but because I really wanted to be able to put something cool togehter for the OLS/ColdFusion community - another option, hopefully high-performance right out of the box, for CF hosting, in a convenient Docker image. I just don't see why it's failing and i need to get back to work. Will offer any config files requested. I'm at a loss.
  4. Pong

    Pong Well-Known Member Staff Member

    If you are talking about Tomcat/Lucee, it is on Java side and there is no cache solution for it. When we talking about the cache, we mean in the php world.
  5. oranuf

    oranuf Member

    I don't understand at all what you are saying. I was successfully caching my Tomcat/Lucee configuration with OLS and the cachng module. It simply wasn't responding to POST actions, which is, as far as I can tell, unrelated. If you're talking about the specific LSCache solution/plugin for WordPress, that's a different story, but unless I'm missing something, does not preclude the use of the caching module in OLS for other applications.
  6. Pong

    Pong Well-Known Member Staff Member

    When we test LScache module on OLS, mainly for PHP applications, either through cache plugin we developed, or rewrite rules, but not for Java, Python, Ruby, NodeJS etc. It is interesting that you can make lscache work with java application. Feel free to share back your successful story, though lscache module doesn't officially support them.
  7. oranuf

    oranuf Member

    There really was no secret to getting it to work... i added the cache module to OLS at the server level, with the base configuration specified in the OLS online docs.

    Then i added a virtual host, and to that host I added an External App: a Servlet Engine, pointing to (The Tomcat AJP port). Then I added a Script handler to that virtual host, to pipe all requests for .cfm pages to that servlet. I then configured a servlet context. lastly, i added my cache configuration for that specific virtual host. I don't recall if I then used the context or the rewrite rules, I'm sure at one point I had both working. My .cfm pages were cached for the time I specified in the rules - in my case 15 seconds for testing. Worked like a charm, my cfm page showed a date and time, and kept that date and time through all refreshes for 15 seconds.

    Too bad form POSTs were not working with this config for some reason, because if they did, i'd have been on my merry way about 4 days ago now.

    As it stands now, I'm running with a Web Server as my External App instead, with a script handler for cfm pages pointing at that, and a Proxy context, and it works fine and seems fast enough (no speed testing comparisons yet), but with no ability to cache... which I thought was a huge point of having things set up as a reverse proxy. I'm pretty confused as to why Proxy won't allow caching, and why Servlet Engine won't do POSTs. but it's left me with a crippled configuration where Lucee/Tomcat are being served okay by OLS, but I'm not able to take advantage of the caching that I wanted to implement in my Docker image as well, for a superb out-of-the-box experience.

Share This Page